| Round 37 | |
| Andrew | Pennsylvania (Ivy): Put away your pencils ... you can penn the Quakers in for sucking. Besides, how can a team named for oatmeal be any good? |
| Brian H. | Manhattan -- Metro Atlantic |
| Matt | I'll take Western Kentucky from the Sun Belt |
| John P. | Champion takes Creighton! |
| John H. | Southern Illinois |
| Brian T. | Valparaiso (Mid-Continent) |
| Round 38 | |
| Brian T. | College of Charleston (Southern) |
| John H. | I’ll take Gonzaga, which will be noted as a stroked of genius as the ‘Zag their way off the bubble by getting spanked by San Diego tonight. |
| John P. | Champion selects Dayton! |
| Matt | Oregon |
| Brian H. | BYU |
| Andrew | Weber State (Big Sky): Some pronounce the Weber State Wildcats as "Wee brrr State." Some say "Web err State." I call them "University of Crap." |
| Round 39 | |
| Andrew | Butler (Horizon): This team of future Mr. Belvederes move around the basketball court like Lurch. |
| Brian H. | California |
| Matt | Georgia |
| John P. | Connecticut |
| John H. | Mississippi State |
| Brian T. | Gimme Utah (Mountain West) |
| Round 40 | |
| Brian T. | and Big 10 Champeen Wisconsin |
| John H. | the Okie State Cowboys of the Big 12, hailing from Stillwater, Oklahoma, but headed for a first round loss! |
| John P. | Champion takes his wife's hometown, Memphis |
| Matt | Pittsburgh |
| Brian H. | Notre Dame |
| Andrew | Maryland (ACC): Remember what happened to the turtle football team when they played Virginia to clinch back-to-back ACC championships? I foresee a similar disaster for the turtle hoops team when they try to defend their national championship. In fact, didn't they just lose to the lowly Cavs on the hardcourt? |
| Round 41 | |
| Andrew | Louisville (Conference USA): If the Cards play a top 20 team, they will lose by at least 10. That is ... unless the game is played in Kentucky, there is a torrential downpour, Ragone is hot from the outside, and their opponent attempts ill-advised, low percentage plays in overtime. |
| Brian H. | Illinois |
| Matt | Florida |
| John P. | Syracuse |
| John H. | Stanford |
| Brian T. | Duke |
| Round 42 | |
| Brian T. | Xavier |
| John H. | Marquette, I guess. how good can they really be? |
| John P. | Champion takes the Deacons! (WF) |
| Matt | I'll take Oklahoma |
| Brian H. | Texas -- i have my kansas hat on so I can't pick them |
| Andrew | Kentucky (SEC): Tubby not only coaches the team, but it describes the physical appearance of the starting five. |