Post Draft Analysis
Andrew's Draft Analysis
1.  Andrew - despite the number 1 pick of the draft, Florida, losing stunningly in the first round to Albany, the other 7 excellent draft picks will come though and Andrew will win back-to-back championships, scoring 12 points this year.  Even though the average seed of his top-4 picks was a league-worst 5.25, Oklahoma, North Carolina, and Pittsburgh should make it to the sweet sixteen and beyond.
2.  Brian H - Brian is tied with Andrew for the worst average seed at 8.88, so the final standings of the top 2 will be the inverse of that measure.  Actually, I do not expect Brian to compete for the title this year with Duke and Wisconsin as his leading ladies. Both have choked of late in the Big Dance. But, he has won the contest so many times that I feel he has earned this predicted rank.  So, I predict he will finish with 6 points, but at the same time will project him at 2nd place.
3.  John - I think Kansas has a legitimate shot at the title this year with Wiggins (damn him and his disloyalty).  Moreover, I really like his picks of Kentucky (though a little early) and Tennessee/Iowa.  If Creighton can hold up their lofty seeding, John will challenge for the title.  He should finish with 11 points, which is a great improvement of his 5 points of last year.
4.  Drum - Drum actually had the best average seed and the best top-4 average seed.  But, he drafted rivals Ohio State and Michigan, and they will make an earlier exit than he projected.  Villanova is not a top-4 team, so Drum will finish out of the money, in 4th place with 9 points.
5.  Derek - Syracuse will decide Derek's fate in this contest.  Will they play like the #1 team, which they were for much of the year?  Or, will they tank like they did in the last 10 games?  I expect them to mirror their regular season in the tournament . . . win their first two games convincingly, but fall apart in game 3.  That said, I expect Arizona to play in the championship game so Derek will get 8 points.
6.  Piet - Drafting from the 8th spot, Piet started out with two very strong picks in Louisville and Michigan State.  But, his draft fell like a rock after that.  He should get 7 points and finish 6th.
7.  Eric - Virginia has looked very, very good this season.  But, they got hammered by Tennessee early this year and that still sticks out to me.  UCLA, San Diego State and Stanford?  Eric drafted way too many middle-of-the-road California teams to compete.  He may scrap for 6 points.  I do expect him to avoid back-to-back doormats.
8.  Brian T - Brian has some very trendy picks, I will admit.  Stephen F Austin is popular 12 v 5 pick.  Iowa State and New Mexico are popular Cinderella teams for the final 4.  Of course, Wichita State went undefeated this year.  But, I think they will all tank in crunch time, and Brian will finish with a measly 4 points.
Derek's Draft Analysis
Here are my unbiased picks.
1) Derek - 12 points (even with an early exit by Syracuse)
2) Piet - 9 points
3) Andrew - 9 points (not bad, Andrew, not bad, but Florida and Dayton can only take you so far)
4) Johns - 8 points
5 & 6) The Brians - 7 points
7) Eric - 6 points
8) Matt - 5 points
I decided to use Nate Silver's probabilities (vs. Karl Rove's predictions) for an even MORE unbiased forecast...
1) Matt - 8.56
2) Derek - 8.48
3) Piet - 8.40
4) John - 7.96
5) Andrew - 7.61
6) Brian H. - 7.60
7) Eric - 7.18
8) Brian T. - 6.35
Piet's Draft Analysis
I am pleased to release the Seed Weighted Ping Pong Ball Bracket results (The SWPPBB replaced the statistically unsound "Trash Can Selection Bracket"):
1. Brian H. (14)
2. Drum (12)
3. Derek (9)
4. Piet (8)
5. Brian T.(7)
6. Eric (6)
7. Andrew (5)
8. John (2)
The complete SWPPBB is available on request.